January 30, 2009

  • My Top 5 Fictional Crushes

    EDIT: Yesterday, I asked SecretNeverTold to do a male version of this list. Read it here. I love #3 and #5, btw, and how in the world did I forget the cute, adventurous Anne of Green Gables? (hangs head in shame).

    I love to read books, and as such, I often find descriptions of female characters that make me wish those ladies were real. So I decided to make a top 5 list of my crushes from literature. Now, I should note that my entries are slanted towards classy, famous literature--you're not going to find Wonderwoman here, nor the heroine of "Midnight Serenade in the Gazebo"-type romance novels.

    1. Jo, Little Women. I loved the physical description of Jo in the Little Women book (no, I won't tell you what I like, look it up! ha). Jo's adventurous nature and mischief always amused me, and the way she turned down Laurie even though she loved him so much was amazing. Oh, and the scene where she's crying when she's with the professor is also adorable.

    2. Eowyn, The Fellowship of the Rings. A woman in distress who rescues herself? You can see the years of desperation that Eowyn went through while her father was led astray by Wormtongue, and her desire for a hero. Then, in the end, she steps up and becomes a heroine herself. She's a warrior herself, which is also attractive. Add to the equation my appreciation for Faramir as the over-worked younger brother, and they may be one of my favorite couples in literature (Faramir and Eowyn).

    3. Eilonwy, Prydain Chronicles. She changes emotions every two seconds and gives poor Taran, the hero of the books, a terrible time. She's always teasing him and being difficult to understand. But she also loves him and has a hilarious, lovely attitude that makes me laugh. It's ok if a woman takes you through a rollercoaster of experiences if she's the right one.

    4. Prue Sarn, Precious Bane. This book is a little more obscure. Prue has a "hare-lip" (what appears to be a cleft palate) and thinks she cannot marry anyone. She spends her time working hard on the farm and helping others with their dreams. But she falls in love with the weaver and eventually, he reciprocates her love and convinces her that she is lovable and rescues her. Just a beautiful story in that there's tragedy throughout the whole book, but all of a sudden the ending is happy.

    5. Hester Prynne, The Scarlet Letter. Ok, we'd have to figure out custody issues for her daughter first, ha. But Hester's ability to rise above her shaming and the ignorance of the men in her life is incredibly attractive. She lives for hope and truth when she could easily despair. There's something about that force of character that just leaves me hoping to someday know and love a woman with that attitude.

    Also receiving votes: Elizabeth Bennett, Jane Eyre, O. Henry's shop girls, Nellie from Little House on the Prairie, The White Witch from Narnia (LOL I know Amy will mock that one), Achren.

    So who are your top 5?

Comments (37)

  • Imagine how awkward it would be walking around with a lady who always wore a huge red "A" embroidered on her chest! When you went on a date, they'd all yell "Adultery, adulteress, and adulterer!"

  • I think I need to read Little Women.   Never did, always thought about it though......

    Holden Caufield.  Love his attitude and how he tries to save the little ones from phonies......

    That's all I can think of on a moment's notice........

  • NELLIE???? What's wrong with you, man? She was awful!

  • @weedorwildflower - LOL I know, I happen to like some of the villains of literature as well. 

  • Nellie!  How could you?

  • @Amanda_Barber - hee-hee. Hey, at least she didn't make the top 5!

  • O? ... as in the story of O? I hear that book is FREAKY. And I heard that from someone who reads freaky books.

    I love Jane Eyre and look up to her. I wish I could be like her. You've definitely opened up an interest in the Precious Bane book, I might want to check that out.

    I loved Faramir from LOTR movie... also Lupin from the Harry Potter movies... as characters in books, I always wanted to hook up with Dr. John Brown from Like Water for Chocolate... he was just such an amazing, kind and wonderful man who basically wound up with no one which I always thought was unfair.

    Oooh, and Capt. Wentworth from Persuasion, and Colonel Brandon from Sense and Sensibility. (Mr. Darcy from Pride and Prejudice is a bit too obvious of a pick is he not?)

  • @GreekPhysique - lol... that's what I get for skimming. I've read many of Austen's books including P&P... although the bbc version is my favorite version of that story. He is kind of a snobby jerk who reforms, but so many women like that character, probably because of Colin Firth's sexy version rather than what they read in the book.   A lot of these characters are broody dudes with something heavy on their minds... not always as attractive to me as to other ladies... that's why I tend to pick the lesser known guys who are simply gentle and kind or more straightforward.

  • I'm so glad to see Eowyn on this list! She's stunning, isn't she? :D

    Top 5 men:

    Joel Pepper, from The Five Little Peppers and How They Grew. Lovely story, sweetest young man. :D

    Aragorn. I don't think I have to explain this one. I mean, really. Well, I'm mortal, and he's got that whole super long life thing going on because of being a ranger... but still...

    Kvothe, from The Name of the Wind. Passionate, musical, and an archanist. He gives fearlessly and without reserve. Admirable.

    Van Helsing, from Dracula. He's intelligent, loving, considerate and one heck of an intellectual. Despite our age difference, I think it could work!

    Roland Deschain from the Gunslinger Series (S.King)... I just love the absolute kickassness of this character. A little weird here and there... and definitely having some psychological issues, but so cool. I think we'd be good partners in crime. :D

  • Top 5? Well, I can at least list a couple.

    Hank Rearden from Atlas Shrugged - I still can't exactly place why I rank him over John Galt or Francisco, but I do. Reasons cannot be put into words as to why I am in love with this man.

    Jonathan Riley from The Little Lady Agency - I found it surprising that I fell in love with a character from such a recent book. This goes all around from the physical description to his personality. Also a shock is that he's the American in the book - I'd've thought I'd like the Brits more. Probably doesn't hurt that he's moderately wealthy. And that he can dance. One I learned that, I was sold! hah.

    That's all I have at the moment. Most of the books I'm reading now...don't have characters. Except The Fountainhead, but I've already read that and didn't fall in love with anyone.

  • I LOVE Little Women! I can't count the times I have read that book. Jo is an awesome character. My fav though was Beth, maybe because I am much like her, quiet.

    I would agree with you on Jane Eyre and Nellie, they were also wonderful women.

    I don't know if I have any fictional crushes, I just enjoy reading...

  • Hmmm
    Mine...
    Raistlin, from the Dragonlance series (he's in many books)
    Edward Dantes/The Count of Monte Cristo (from the same book)
    Maniac Magee (from the book of the same title)
    Tasslehoff Burrfoot (Dragonlance, again)
    Pierre Arronax (20,000 Leagues Under the Sea)

  • I'm gonna have to work on this...:) Awesome list. 

  • any Emilie Loring male character. seriously. and any Jane Austen male character.

    I'm not picky.

    ha!

  • Francisco d'Anconia, Atlas Shrugged

    Gatsby, The Great Gatsby

    Boromir & Gandalf, LOTR

    Charles Ryder, Brideshead Revisited

    Atticus Finch, To Kill a Mockingbird

  • I LOVE your list. Such a diversity. : ) And I grew up wanting to BE Jo March. I might have failed miserably, but I still adore her.

  • Sounds like I need to read Precious Bane. :)

  • Well done. I will have to think on this one a bit. 

  • the white witch? very interesting... how come?

  • I get literary crushes a lot.  Good pick on the Eowyn/Faramir relationship, I love them, too.

    These aren't ranked, just numbered as they come to mind.

    1. Eomer from Lord of the Rings

    2. Will Ladislaw from Middlemarch

    3. Zooey Glass from Franny and Zooey

    4. Charles Darnay and Sydney Carton from A Tale of Two Cities.  Sorry, I never could decide who I liked more.

    5. ex-P.F.C. Wintergreen from Catch-22.  Don't ask me to explain this one because I can't; he might be one that I'll get over in a year or two. 

    Also receiving nods are Tertius Lydgate from Middlemarch, Faramir from Lord of the Rings, and Mr. Knightley from Emma.

  • Ahhh, your list is totally cute! I love it! Jo is one of my favorite book characters, ever! She's so awesome! Eowyn is quite amazing as well... she was one of my favorites from LOTR. As for my list...

    1) Michael Hosea from Redeeming Love.

    2) Faramir

    3) Marcus from The Mark of the Lion Series

    4) Johnis from The Lost Books

    5) Of course... Mr. Darcy. 

  • I very much agree with the Eowyn selection. Arwen got far too much attention as far as I'm concerned.

  • I don't recall ever having a crush on a character from a book.

    But to play along, I will list male characters that I have admired for their character:

    1) abbe from Les Miserables
    2) Atticus Finch, TKAM
    3) Harry Maylie of Oliver Twist

    Guys, I don't want women that I care for dating:
    1) Vronsky, Oblonsky, Karenin from Anna K
    2) Angel and Alec from Tess D, both annoying
    3) the Other man in M. Bovary
    4) Andrei from W and P
    5) Jane Eyre's guy
    6) Howard Roark
    7) Hamlet
    8) Romeo
    9) All the men in Their Eyes Were Watching God

    Men I wouldn't want men I cared for to become:
    1) Sidney Cartier of ATTC
    2) Pip of Great Expectations

  • @hilaw - Oh, yeah!  Atticus.  I truly cried my eyes out when Gregory Peck died.  He was such a wonderful Atticus.

  • great entry.  and being mediterranean myself, i'm not surprised you like the dark-haired yet sassy maidens.  jo was always my favorite.

  • cute, cute, cute! I love each of these characters and am tickled to see someone else thought the same (although maybe I wouldn't crush on them )

    I'll try to post my list tomorrow. Thanks, GP.

  • @unshakeablekingdom -  Shh, don't tell anyone else! haha Yes, I am a big fan of Mediterranean looks and attitude

  • You're going to have to justify why Ms. Bennett was a runner up....

  • Gilbert Blythe, Mr. Darcy, Danny Watkins from the Smart Chick Mysteries, Barney Snaith from the Blue Castle, Aragorn.

    And, Edward Cullen, probably.

  • Not that I really lacked any before, but reading this list makes me respect you more. Especially because Jo March is first. I may steal this idea at some point, but it'll take a while to narrow it down...

  • Scarlett O'Hara

    Dorothy of Oz

    Jo of Little Women

    Celie of The Color Purple

    Morgaine of Mists of Avalon

    oops I did all heroines, no heros...hmmm, I'll have to think about that.

  • What a good idea! I might have to steal this one, seeing as I've got nothing else to yarn about. But really. That's nice. The White Witch though... has me doubting ;)

  • Your first two women have always been two of my top fictional female role models :D  

  • Awesome. I love O'Henry's shop girls.

  • @skittlesruletheworld - I was in Texas earlier this year and went to restaurant. Outside they had random plaque saying "O Henry once lived here." When I saw it, I nearly screamed. I'm a big fan, haha. 

  • @GreekPhysique - Where is that? I live in Texas. I really love O'Henry too. A good short story is in its own league of awesome.

  • @skittlesruletheworld - Austin, Texas. It's right across the street from the conference center. So glad to find fellow admirer of O. Henry!

Comments are closed.

Post a Comment